Home    Subscribe    Write for Us    FAQ    Contact    HubGarden    Login

Should a farmer have the right to shoot a dog they believe has harmed one of their livestock?

by Maria (follow)
Chief Editor at craftbuddies.hubgarden.com/ and niftynailart.hubgarden.com/
Pet Care (142)      Behaviour (43)      Questions (39)      Welfare (5)      Farming (1)      Attack (1)     
Source via morguefile.com

It is an age old question which divides many people. A wandering dog enters a barnyard or field and threatens or kills some of the livestock.

Should a farmer have the right to shoot this dog without any notice to the owner or any proof that that particular dog has carried out the attack.

Do you think it is right or wrong?

Should the farmer try to catch the dog and return him/her to their owner?

Who is at fault?

#Pet Care
I like this Question - 6
Do you have a pet story or helpful tips and tricks to share with other pet owners? You can get paid for submitting your original articles, product reviews or pet tips! Apply here.
[ Submit an Answer ]
Top Answers
"Should a farmer have the right to shoot this dog without any notice to the owner or any proof that that particular dog has carried out the attack." - My oath they have they should and they do. The damage both physical and financial that can be done by these dogs is enormous.These dogs might be cute and cuddly at home but they can maul farm animals very quickly when running loose, just chasing farm animals can cause broken legs etc. The farmer does not have to wait until his stock has been harmed he has a legal obligation to protect his stock from unnecessary pain and discomfort
Excellent question!
And what a difficult one.

I guess the owners are at fault however having lived on 5 acres with dogs and llamas as well as smaller animals, this was sometimes difficult.

People would leave the front gates open and so the dogs got out -occasionally there was a problem with the fencing which we were not aware of until a dog was out.

I know this is all the owner's responsibility however I do not think it is fair to just shoot a dog without a warning.

And also without proof or photo of the event -I would rather report it, with the photo to the ranger and let the council decide.

I understand that there are problems with this as what if an animal is killing a whole lot of farm animals? I think then perhaps you need to take steps to stop him but not to shoot him dead.

As I said, it is a very difficult question and depends which side you are coming from, and each situation is different.

I am sure however that farmers on really large properties do this anyway and no one would know what has happened to their dog.

Either way, it is a horrible thing....
by Finy
"Should a farmer have the right to shoot this dog without any notice to the owner or any proof that that particular dog has carried out the attack" - They have they should and they do.A farmer has a legal and moral right to protect his livestock (and income) from any injury or stress. That 1kg dog might look cute chasing his cows around his paddock but can cause him thousands of dollars in loses due to broken legs etc not to mention the fact that stressed animals do not perform well."And also without proof or photo of the event -I would rather report it, with the photo to the ranger and let the council decide." So in the meantime the livestock continue to be stressed and injured . The only time i had a problem with a dog i warned the owner once he obviously didn't listen because the next time i seen the dog the cows had pulverized it.

I really don't think too many farmers out there wish to shoot someones dog for fun - at least I hope to think so - but there are many who do not want to shoot their livestock that they have spent so long caring for because a dog has caused it injuries - the farmer has a right in my opinion to shoot an animal that may cause serious damage to one or more of his animals. Although I do believe that there are other options in some cases like if the animal seems approachable to capture it and contain it whilst trying to locate it's owners.
I know this sounds terrible but it comes from a vegetarian daughter of an ex cattle farmer.
If you live in Ontario you are allowed to shoot any dog that is a hazard to your animals. I use to have a hobby farm with dairy goats, cats, dogs and anything that wondered in. The farmed next door had a few pigs, cows and lambs. One spring a new neighbour had two large Puddle dogs, they killed one of my cats and one of our pet rabbits, and a lot of piglets. The farmer next door shot both of them and hung their hides on the neighbours gate. They had been warned to keep the dogs tied up, and they paid the price, they went back to England.
More Articles by Maria
When we think of dogs and bones we automatically think the two go hand in hand, however we don't oft...
For a lot of us, our pets are almost like children
Nowadays there are so many vet recommended special diets for pets to combat all sorts of health pr...
3 answers
Once you have organised a Pet Medical History, Vaccinations and Microchipping for your new pet, its ...
I was recently on the hunt for a set of pet grooming clippers to use on my shaggy-haired Bichon ...
It is astonishing to see the amount of pet owners who leave their pet in a car on a hot day to "...
4 answers
view all articles by Maria
Articles by Maria on Other Hubs
My Google Plus Profile
ID: 33403
Trending Articles
Pets can be a wonderful addition to the family and they can bring many benefits, but when they are...
Puppies and dogs are fun and can make a wonderful addition to the family, but are you really ready? ...
There are times in life when two households with existing pets will combine, and it can be quite d...
Perhaps you have written articles for other Hub Garden hubs and now you want to have a go at writi...
Don’t let your pet’s food and water dishes become a science experiment
Canine Dental hygiene is key part of maintaining your dog’s overall health and wellbeing
Shooting (pictures of!) dogs is like any other sort or photography with its own charms, quirks and...
**%%Loves Me, Loves Me Not?%%** Cats have always been a bit of an enigma…
We all enjoy the beauty that greenery and flowers bring inside our homes
When parents bring a new baby into their home, they take every precaution to make it safe
Dogs (156)
Cats (66)
Birds (13)
Horses (3)
Health (38)
Pets (30)
Feeding (27)
Safety (10)
Dog (5)
Summer (4)
Llamas (4)
Diet (3)
Toxic (3)
Cat (3)
Fleas (3)
Fowl (3)
Grief (3)
Dental (3)
Featured on Other Hubs
Copyright 2012-2018 On Topic Media PTY LTD. ABN 18113479226. mobile version